Opinion: Players are rich. Owners are rich. What does a salary cap do for us?
This is an opinion column. Players make a lot of money and owners make even more, so as fans we should judge the salary cap by what it does for us. Going through what fans care about most, a cap doesn't lower ticket prices or end blackouts, it makes keeping stars harder, the fixes for low-spending teams work without it, and it's the one thing putting next season at risk. In all honesty, the best case is that a cap leaves us where we are.
Every time owners and players fight over money, you've probably heard someone call the fight millionaires against billionaires, so who cares? I get it. Players make a lot of money, owners make even more, and neither side needs our sympathy.
We as fans still have a stake in this, though. The owners say they won't sign a deal without a salary cap, so the question for us is what a cap would change for the people buying the tickets and watching the games.
So let's walk through the things fans care about most, one at a time.
What we pay. A cap limits what teams pay players, and it says nothing about what teams charge us. Teams price tickets by demand, and after the NHL got its hard cap in 2005, its ticket prices went up about 25% in five years. See the numbers. Neutral at best.
Being able to watch. Blackouts come from MLB's broadcast rules. Pooling TV rights could be agreed with or without a cap. Neutral.
Keeping our stars. Under a hard cap, a raise for one star comes out of what the rest of the roster can make. In the capped leagues, even teams that just won a title trade away stars to stay under the limit. See the cases. Worse for us.
A real shot at October. Seventeen different teams have won the World Series since 2000, more than the NHL (14), NBA (13) or NFL (13) in the same years. The teams that really fall behind are mostly the ones whose owners put a small share of their revenue into the team. A salary floor and more revenue sharing help with low spending, and both sides have proposed versions of each. Check your team. A cap puts a limit on the biggest payrolls and leaves the smallest ones where they are.
A full season. The cap is the sticking point in the talks. If we lose games this winter, the cap is why. Worse for us.
Putting it all together, a cap leaves what we pay and what we can watch the same as today. On keeping stars and getting a full season, a cap makes things harder for us. And the fixes that would give every team a fair shot work without a cap. In all honesty, the best case is that a cap leaves us where we are, and the worst case costs us stars and games.
So the next time the argument turns into who's richer, what does a cap actually do for us fans? I haven't found a way a cap makes things better for us. If you have, I'd love to hear it. Take the fan check and cast your vote.
— Sonny, a fan
Where do you stand?
Take the fan check to see how a cap lines up with what you care about, then cast your vote for or against.
Take the 60-second fan check8 quick questions. No sign-up. See your result instantly.
Last updated