Opinion: Baseball's unwritten rule is that owners compete too
This is an opinion column. Owning a team is the ultimate rich person's game: most owners made their fortunes in real businesses elsewhere and bought a team to compete for the bragging rights. Baseball has always been about that competition, with the money coming second, and fans chase the same bragging rights. When an owner keeps payroll low and pockets the profit, the deal between owners and fans is broken, and fans feel it. A salary cap limits the owners who are trying to win and does nothing about the ones who aren't. A floor, or a rule that shared money goes back into the team, would hold every owner to the deal.
Think about what you give your team every year. You buy the tickets, wear the jersey and argue all winter about whose team is better. In return, we expect one thing from the people who own our teams, and nobody ever had to write it down. We expect them to try to win.
Owning a team is the ultimate rich person's game. Most owners made their fortunes somewhere else first, in real businesses, and then bought a team to compete. They want the trophy and the bragging rights over the other owners, the same way we want bragging rights over the fan in the next seat. Baseball has lasted 150 years on that competition, and the money has always come second.
Most owners still hold up their end. Across the league, teams put about 48% of their revenue into payroll in 2025, and plenty spent well above that share to chase October.
Some owners don't. In 2025 the Marlins put 27% of their revenue into payroll, the lowest share in baseball, and still made $53 million. The Pirates put in 33%, made $48 million and haven't made the playoffs in ten seasons. See every team's numbers. When an owner keeps payroll low, collects revenue-sharing money and keeps the profit, the deal is broken.
Fans notice. In my experience, when a fan base is fed up with how its team plays, the owner usually isn't competing. Fans can see the profits and they can see the roster, and they can tell a team that's rebuilding from an owner who isn't trying.
Here's what bothers me about the salary cap. A cap goes after the owners who spend the most to win, the ones holding up their end. The owners who aren't trying stay where they are, because a cap limits the biggest payrolls and leaves the smallest ones alone.
If the goal is to hold every owner to the deal, I think there are better ways to get there. A salary floor makes every team spend something. A rule that revenue-sharing money has to go back into the team, to players, staff and the fan experience, makes sure shared money goes toward winning. See how a floor and a cap differ. Both sides have proposed versions of each.
So what should the rules do: push every owner to compete, or cap the ones who already do?
— Sonny, a fan
Where do you stand?
Take the fan check to see how a cap lines up with what you care about, then cast your vote for or against.
Take the 60-second fan check8 quick questions. No sign-up. See your result instantly.
Last updated