MLB's salary cap video, point by point: what it says and what it leaves out
Many of its numbers check out, but they don't all say what the video implies. Its headline stat, that large-market teams won 90% of recent World Series, matches if large market means the 15 teams in the 12 biggest metro areas. Measured by payroll, which is what a cap limits, only 4 of the last 10 champions had a top-five payroll and 3 ranked outside the top 10.
On November 14, MLB released a five-minute video with Morgan Sword, its head of baseball operations, making the case for a salary cap and floor. Watch it first, then go through it with us point by point.
"90 percent of the World Series champions" came from large markets
The video says: over the last decade, teams from large markets made up 64% of postseason teams, 75% of LCS teams, 85% of World Series teams and 90% of champions.
What it leaves out: it never says which teams count as "large market." The video's whole argument is about payroll, but this number is about city size. A team can be in a big city and still spend in the middle of the pack, or near the bottom: the White Sox play in the third-biggest metro area and had the 29th-highest payroll in 2025. Small market and low spender aren't the same thing.
We checked it. MLB's figures match exactly if "large market" means the teams in the 12 biggest metro areas. That definition covers 15 of the 30 teams: half the league. It also leaves just two groups, so San Francisco, the 13th-biggest metro, counts as small market alongside Milwaukee, a metro about a third its size. So big-city teams do win more often than their share. But the video's argument is about payroll, and a cap doesn't change city size. Measured by payroll, the thing a cap actually limits, the picture changes:
| Season | Champion | Metro size rank (of 27) | Payroll rank that year (of 30) |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2017 | Houston Astros | #5 | #19 |
| 2018 | Boston Red Sox | #12 | #1 |
| 2019 | Washington Nationals | #8 | #6 |
| 2020 | Los Angeles Dodgers | #2 | #5 |
| 2021 | Atlanta Braves | #7 | #13 |
| 2022 | Houston Astros | #5 | #9 |
| 2023 | Texas Rangers | #4 | #8 |
| 2024 | Los Angeles Dodgers | #2 | #1 |
| 2025 | Los Angeles Dodgers | #2 | #1 |
| 2026 | Milwaukee Brewers | #27 | #19 |
- 9 of 10 champions came from the 12 biggest metro areas, as MLB says.
- Only 4 of 10 had a top-five payroll.
- 3 of 10 ranked outside the top 10 in payroll: the 2017 Astros (#19), the 2021 Braves (#13) and the 2026 Brewers (#19).
- Of the 20 World Series teams since 2017, 6 ranked outside the top 10 in payroll, including Tampa Bay twice at #27.
Metro size: US Census Bureau 2025 metro estimates (Toronto: Statistics Canada). Payroll: Spotrac luxury-tax payroll rank in the championship season. MLB's video does not state which teams it counts as large market; the 12-biggest-metros definition is the one that reproduces its numbers.
What it means for us: a cap can't make Milwaukee a bigger city. It can only limit what teams spend, and spending was a weaker predictor of titles than the video suggests.
"It had been over a decade since a small-market team last won"
The video says: before this year, no small-market team had won the World Series in over a decade, while 16 small-market teams won titles in the other major US sports.
What it leaves out: again, no definition of "small market," in baseball or in the other leagues. And "small market" is used as if it meant a low-spending team, or a team at a disadvantage. It means neither. By the same large/small split that matches the video's numbers, 7 of the 10 most profitable clubs in 2025 were small-market teams: San Francisco, Cleveland, Pittsburgh, Milwaukee, the Athletics, St. Louis and Tampa Bay. Small market and low spender aren't the same thing.
The video also came out two weeks after small-market Milwaukee beat Tampa Bay, another low-payroll club, in the World Series. Over the same years the capped leagues had fewer different champions than baseball: since 2000, 17 franchises have won the World Series, against 14 in the NHL and 13 each in the NBA and NFL.
"The difference from the top to the bottom-spending club is $446 million"
The video says: the gap between the highest and lowest payroll is unthinkable in any other league.
What it leaves out: a top-to-bottom gap compares the two most extreme teams. It says nothing about the 28 in between. In 2025's final payrolls, the middle half of the league spent between $140 million and $247 million. And the top of the gap is one club: the Dodgers spent $71 million more than any other team. Take them out and the 2025 top-to-bottom gap drops from $330 million to $260 million.
The Dodgers are also the only club that pays into revenue sharing on a TV value fixed in their 2012 bankruptcy settlement, not on their real TV income like every other team. That exemption reportedly saves them $50 to $55 million in 2026 alone. Fixing it would narrow the biggest gap in the league, and it doesn't take a cap.
"The top four clubs spent more than the bottom 22 combined on free agents"
What it leaves out: free agency is one way to build a team. Small-market winners like Milwaukee, Tampa Bay and Cleveland built mostly through the draft, trades and extensions. Free-agent spending alone doesn't show who can compete.
"The top five payroll teams averaged 89 wins; the bottom five, 74"
This one is fair, as far as it goes: on average, spending more does help. But notice the measure: regular-season wins. When we fans talk about winning, we mean making it to October, and going deep once we're there. On that measure, only 4 of the last 10 champions had a top-five payroll. Our own look at 2017 to 2026 finds spending helps, with big exceptions. The Angels were among the top dozen spenders and never made the playoffs, while the Brewers, Guardians and Rays ranked in the bottom eight and made it 8, 7 and 6 times. And a cap only limits the top spenders; it doesn't make a 74-win team's owner spend more. The floor is the part that would make that owner spend more.
"In the smallest markets, if they lose those big stars, that could mean the end of your season"
What it leaves out: injuries sink big-market teams too. In 2026 the Mets, with one of the highest payrolls of the last decade, lost long stretches from stars Francisco Lindor and Juan Soto, who played just 44 games together. The Mets were in last place by September.
"Players' total compensation goes up"
What it leaves out: the players' union says the 50-50 split isn't real. Under MLB's definitions, owners would deduct billions before splitting, leave out revenue such as franchise sales, expansion fees and ballpark-area real estate, and count costs like signing bonuses, retirement benefits and clubhouse meals against the players' half. The union estimates players would have lost over half a billion dollars in 2026 under the plan.
"A recent independent poll showed 79 percent of fans support a cap and floor"
What it leaves out: that poll, by Morning Consult, was taken in November 2025, just after the Dodgers won their second straight title. The more recent HarrisX poll asked about a cap "similar to the NFL and NBA" and didn't ask whether fans expect it to lower ticket prices. We're running our own fan vote. Results go up in batches, every 100 confirmed votes, and stay live on the site. Add yours.
"The cap and floor go together"
The video says: even if the smallest-market teams added $50 to $70 million, without a cap they would still be hundreds of millions behind the biggest spenders.
What it leaves out: this is the video's strongest point, and it's true: a floor alone won't close the gap with the biggest spenders. But the question for fans isn't whether the gap closes. It's whether our team can make October and win there. Milwaukee just won the World Series with the 19th-highest payroll, over Tampa Bay, another team below the proposed floor. A floor would raise what low-spending teams put into payroll, with or without a cap. Does a team need to match the Dodgers to win, or just spend enough to compete?
"It's hard to buy a jersey when your favorite player will end up in New York or LA"
What it leaves out: in capped leagues, teams regularly trade or release stars to stay under the cap, even right after winning titles. See the cases. And the same video lists earlier free agency as one of the plan's benefits, which means our homegrown stars can reach the market, and leave, a year sooner.
"It will finally allow us to address local blackouts"
What it leaves out: blackouts come from MLB's own broadcast rules, and pooling local TV money could be negotiated without a cap. Reporting also notes it wouldn't end national blackouts.
So where does that leave us?
The video gets some things right: spending helps on average, and some owners spend too little. But its biggest numbers rest on terms it never defines, and its fixes for blackouts and low spending don't require a cap. Watch it again with that in mind, and decide for yourself.
Where do you stand?
Take the fan check to see how a cap lines up with what you care about, then cast your vote for or against.
Take the 60-second fan check8 quick questions. No sign-up. See your result instantly.
Sources
- US Census Bureau: Metropolitan area population estimates, 2025
- Statistics Canada: Census metropolitan area population estimates, Table 17-10-0148-01
- TSN: What the Mets learned in 2026
- MLB: Baseball's payroll disparity problem explained (video and transcript, Nov 14, 2026)
- MLB on YouTube: The Case for a Salary Cap and Floor
- Forbes: Head of MLBPA outlines why MLB's cap proposal is a non-starter
- Awful Announcing via Yahoo: Dodgers' revenue-sharing advantage (Aug 2026)
- Forbes: MLB team valuations 2026 (operating income for the 2025 season)
- Spotrac: MLB luxury-tax payrolls by season
- MLB Stats API: standings and postseason results
Last updated